the formula is correct and it does give dark helmet,u cant except to get something in one or few tries , try more times may be little hard to get
(if u get defensive Armour it can also be used to get long handled axe- those formula r added to database)
or another way is if u have junior alchemy try this
wolf bracer + wolf tooth + wolf bracer
this have a better chance, since junior is better than primary
edit
----
lol it thought no one posted an answer here xD but after the post i just saw 2 more have been posted hehehehe ^^
IGN = taisan, Guild =*none*, Server =Leo1
timezone = GMT +5:00 (Maldives)
Spoiler: